Another tribute to AMR. I chose for the subject the different versions of Alice, she is my favorite character ^^
Ok...I admit that in the game was not too clear..
but contrary to popular belief The Red Queen is not Lizzie! The Red Queen is officially Alice.
Read Here -> [link]
****** EDIT! More explanations !from Alice wikia
---> [link]" My Lizzie "
In the Infernal Train, Alice walks up to the Queen and says, "My Lizzie... what is this train's destination?" This has created confusion for many players.
It is possible that Alice was not addressing the Queen directly as "Lizzie" but was instead saying her sister's name out loud in a third-person manner. In the previous scene, Bumby and Alice were discussing Alice's sister thus Alice would have her sister on her mind.
Afterwards, the Queen says, "And that noise wasn't Lizzie talking in her sleep." which supports that the Queen is not an incarnation of Elizabeth Liddell.
The Caterpillar says the Queen is "someone [Alice] once knew and loved. Time changes us all." to which Alice replies, "Not all change is good!" While the first part suggests the Queen is Alice's sister, the "time changes us all" likely refers to Alice as a young child. By "not all change is good", Alice could be referring to her shattered life which worsened after the fire.
I'm happy that the queen is Alice like in the first game
I never liked the fans theory of "Lizzie = Red Queen"
Alice Madness Returns is © by American McGee